Big Mistakes Netflix series is a dark comedy-thriller created by Dan Levy and Rachel Sennott, streaming exclusively on Netflix with a confirmed April 9 release date. The show centres on two siblings who get blackmailed into working for organised crime — a premise that takes everything fans loved about Levy’s warmth and wit and drags it somewhere considerably more dangerous.
Why Big Mistakes Netflix Could Be the Show of the Year
Dan Levy is not coasting on nostalgia here. Co-creating with Rachel Sennott, best known for the sharp, anarchic comedy Bottoms, Levy is signalling from the outset that Big Mistakes will not be a gentle sitcom about family redemption. The blackmail-into-organised-crime premise is a genuine tonal leap, and the trailer makes that clear fast. Lines like “You fuck with my family, you fuck with me” and “Fear has this ability to coerce us into doing things we never envisioned ourselves doing” suggest a show that earns its thriller label rather than wearing it as a marketing badge.
Levy also serves as showrunner, which matters. He is not a hired gun on someone else’s project — this is his vision, shaped by the same instincts that made Schitt’s Creek one of the most rewatchable comedies of the last decade. His 2024 feature directorial debut Good Grief demonstrated he could handle tonal complexity on screen. Big Mistakes looks like the next step in that evolution.
Big Mistakes Netflix vs Schitt’s Creek: What Actually Changes
The comparison to Schitt’s Creek is inevitable and, frankly, useful. Schitt’s Creek built its audience on warmth — a fish-out-of-water family learning to be decent people in a small town. Big Mistakes keeps the chaotic family dynamics but strips out the safety net. Where Schitt’s Creek resolved tension with humour and heart, the trailer for Big Mistakes suggests consequences that actually bite. The blackmail plot, the organised crime entanglement, the line “When the phone rings, you answer” — these are not the rhythms of a cosy comedy.
That tonal shift is the gamble. Schitt’s Creek fans who want more of the same may find Big Mistakes unsettling in exactly the right way, or they may find the darker register alienating. Levy’s bet is that his audience has grown with him, and given how Good Grief performed on Netflix, that bet looks reasonable.
The Cast That Makes Big Mistakes Worth Watching
Levy’s casting choices are doing real work here. Taylor Ortega, known from Ghosts US, steps into the sibling lead role, and Levy has been vocal about his belief she is about to become a household name — a bold claim, but one that suggests he has seen something in her performance worth backing. Laurie Metcalf, whose credits include Lady Bird and Sharp Objects, plays the mother, and Levy’s comment that it has been his “life’s mission” to call Metcalf “mother” on screen is both funny and telling about the dynamic the show is building.
The wider ensemble includes Jack Innanen from Adults, Boran Kuzum from Thank You Next, Abby Quinn from Knock at the Cabin, Elizabeth Perkins from Sharp Objects, Jacob Gutierrez from Dear Evan, Joe Barbara from FBI, and Mark Ivanir from Emilia Pérez. That last credit is worth noting — Ivanir comes into Big Mistakes off the back of one of 2024’s most talked-about films, and his presence adds genuine weight to the organised crime side of the story.
Is Big Mistakes worth watching for Schitt’s Creek fans?
If you loved Schitt’s Creek for its family chaos and Dan Levy’s specific brand of emotionally intelligent humour, Big Mistakes is built directly for you — with the caveat that the stakes are considerably higher and the comedy considerably darker. The blackmail premise and crime thriller elements are not decorative; they appear central to the show’s tension. Levy has described it as a “truly chaotic family story,” and the trailer delivers on that description.
When does Big Mistakes come out on Netflix?
Big Mistakes premieres on April 9, announced via an Instagram post featuring a Sunset Strip billboard with the date spelled out in a sparkly necklace. The show streams exclusively on Netflix as part of a standard subscription. No specific pricing details were listed in the announcement, so standard Netflix subscription tiers apply depending on your region.
Who created Big Mistakes on Netflix?
Big Mistakes was co-created by Dan Levy, who also stars and serves as showrunner, and Rachel Sennott, best known for the 2022 comedy Bottoms. Levy previously made his feature directorial debut with Good Grief in 2024, also for Netflix. The show was announced last year and has been building anticipation since Levy first described the project publicly.
Big Mistakes arrives at exactly the right moment — Netflix needs a prestige comedy-thriller with genuine creative authorship behind it, and Dan Levy needs a project that proves Schitt’s Creek was a foundation, not a ceiling. April 9 cannot come fast enough.
Where to Buy
Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max 2023 | Google Chromecast with Google TV
Edited by the All Things Geek team.
Source: T3
